Trying to decide between these two 17" MBPs - based on cost, longevity, etc.
1) Core i5 2.53Ghz, 8GB DDR3, 1TB HDD, NVidia 330 512MB, High-res glossy screen - currently under the initial year warranty until May, at which point I'd need to shell out and buy Apple Care, which would take it through 2013. $1450
or
2) Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz, 8GB DDR3, 500GB HDD, Nvidia 9600 512MB, High-res AG screen - has Apple Care until April, 2012. $1150
I'm really stumped on this one. On the one hand, the 1st one would have a longer warranty and would also have the newer Core i processor. It's a great price already, but I'd need to buy Apple Care, which would run me $240. It also has the $100+ 1TB drive in it.
The second one is a great deal, wouldn't need Apple Care, but it would only be under warranty another year, and also has the older C2D processor. Anyone have any thoughts? Assuming both machines would serve my needs presently, which one would you get based on longevity and price? Or simply, which is the better deal in terms of hardware and price?
Thanks in advance.
Reply 1 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
Quote:
Originally Posted by QueenOfSpades
Trying to decide between these two 17" MBPs - based on cost, longevity, etc.
1) Core i5 2.53Ghz, 8GB DDR3, 1TB HDD, NVidia 330 512MB, High-res glossy screen - currently under the initial year warranty until May, at which point I'd need to shell out and buy Apple Care, which would take it through 2013. $1450
or
2) Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz, 8GB DDR3, 500GB HDD, Nvidia 330 512MB, High-res AG screen - has Apple Care until April, 2012. $1150
I'm really stumped on this one. On the one hand, the 1st one would have a longer warranty and would also have the newer Core i processor. It's a great price already, but I'd need to buy Apple Care, which would run me $240. It also has the $100+ 1TB drive in it.
The second one is a great deal, wouldn't need Apple Care, but it would only be under warranty another year, and also has the older C2D processor. Anyone have any thoughts? Assuming both machines would serve my needs presently, which one would you get based on longevity and price? Or simply, which is the better deal in terms of hardware and price?
Thanks in advance.
|
I'm very sure that the MBPs equipped with Core2Duo CPUs come with the Nvidia 9400M/9600M GT combo & not the Nvidia GT330/Intel IGP combo.
Anyway, I'll take
option 1. Good luck.
Reply 2 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
Quote:
Originally Posted by SPEEDwithJJ
I'm very sure that the MBPs equipped with Core2Duo CPUs come with the Nvidia 9400M/9600M GT combo & not the Nvidia GT330/Intel IGP combo.
Anyway, I'll take option 1. Good luck.
|
Oh yeah, you're right, that was a typo. Thanks for your advice, I'm leaning that way.
Reply 3 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
It depends what your going to do with it... and if you need the better power in the more expensive one or not.
Reply 4 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
Quote:
Originally Posted by doh123
It depends what your going to do with it... and if you need the better power in the more expensive one or not.
|
For what I do right now, I'm sure the C2D could handle it. Some light gaming, Adobe Creative Suite, light/medium video editing. But I'd like to keep this MBP for at least a few years, which makes the i5 a little more attractive. C2D is also pretty old at this point. Still pondering, but leaning toward the i5.
Reply 5 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
Option 1, IMO.
Reply 6 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
I like option 1.
Reply 7 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
Why does Apple limit its graphics card to below 1 GB? I have a sony from a couple years ago and it has a 512 mb card.q
Reply 8 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
Quote:
Originally Posted by shriek11
Why does Apple limit its graphics card to below 1 GB? I have a sony from a couple years ago and it has a 512 mb card.q
|
you'd have to learn about vram and marketing... many computer and graphics card makers will throw tons of extra ram on one so it looks better and they can up the price and make more profit off very cheap ram... even if it doesn't even improve performance at all.
The current high end 15 and the 17 are the first Mac laptops to have 1gb in them... the two the ops are looking at are both older models.
Reply 9 : which of these 17" MBPs would you buy?
The cards are similar of the platforms I was thinking of and I have seen my older mac lag even in firefox if video is being played unlike my windows machiens, especially with divx ones.
Now, don't tell me divx is stupid and buggy and needs to be killed off as well!